Weather United States of America, Ashburn United States of America, Ashburn 0°C

Diplomacyindia.com


Rajnath Singh in Islamabad : A Visit Well-leveraged

Rajnath Singh in Islamabad : A Visit Well-leveraged
August 14
11:02 2016

asho-behuriaAshok Behuria

Dr Ashok Behuria is a Fellow at Indian Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (IDSA).
The views expressed here are his own

“Analysts in India should stop taking the visit as a give-away and look at it as a sign of India emerging as a confident power, ready to walk the mile in its commitment to strengthen the process of regional integration under SAARC, as the dominant country in the neighbourhood.”

 

Indian Home Minister Rajnath Singh’s visit to Islamabad to attend the 7th SAARC Interior and Home Ministers’ Conference on August 4, 2016 is being subjected to uncharitable analysis in India upon his return, especially because of the perceived coldness (bordering on hostility) with which he was treated. It is, however, necessary to look at the visit objectively and put things in the right perspective.

As much as the approach of the present government does not show any predictable trajectory towards Pakistan, the decision of the Indian government to send Mr Singh to Islamabad at this juncture was a rather sensible and mature move. There was a need for India to show its Interest in the SAARC and the whole idea of regional integration.

Despite the downturn in relations between the two countries during the post-Pathankot days, which even plummeted further in the aftermath of Burhan Wani killing in Jammu and Kashmir, it required real guts and gumption to visit Pakistan for a multilateral engagement with its neighbouring SAARC countries. That Bangladeshi Home Minister chose not to attend the meeting should not be seen as a responsible move which could have been imitated by the Indian Home Minister.

As the predominant country in terms of population, size, resources and security-spending, India has a critical role to play in enabling SAARC as a regional forum. India needs to work closely with all the sister countries of SAARC to address common issues of concern and lead the discussions on these issues and evolve collective approaches to them. Seen from this perspective, Indian Home Minister’s visit to the minister-level meet in Islamabad as a preparatory meeting for the upcoming summit in Islamabad in November this year, should not have been cancelled. Indian non-participation would have amounted to conveying a negative signal to other member countries and smacked of either highhandedness or diplomatic timidity, especially in the wake of the ongoing turmoil in Kashmir.

Therefore, Singh’s visit was apt, justified and quite a bold move. There was no attempt to have any bilateral discussions on the side-lines. It was well known that it would have been untimely and counter-productive. The Indian government must have had its ears to the ground and known that the anti-India constituency was clearly ascendant and the Pakistani interior minister, Chaudhury Nisar Ali Khan, known for his proximity to the deep state of Pakistan (read the military) would not have been the right person to have a dialogue with at the moment.

It was easy to predict therefore that the two ministers would not even shake hands or exchange greetings. The picture of SAARC home ministers with Nawaz Sharif in the media, says it all. If one can read the face of Nisar, it was stiff and unsure as ever, and Rajnath (and even Nawaz!) was struggling to hide his sense of embarrassment from the camera. And if Nisar went away after inviting the delegates for lunch, disregarding basic courtesy as a host, it did reflect badly on him and Pakistan, not on Rajnath. Other SAARC ministers must have taken due note of the poor taste of Pakistani hospitality. It did not show Pakistan in good light.

Similarly, the permission granted to jihadi leaders like Hafiz Saeed and Salahuddin to lead protest demonstrations against Rajnath Singh over the issue of Kashmir during his visit did not show Pakistani government in good light either. It proved the long-standing Indian contention once again that the government of Pakistan has been sponsoring and encouraging such terror groups while pretending to take action against terrorists of all hues—good and bad!

Moreover, the Indian Home Minister, without mentioning the name of Pakistan, as per the SAARC tradition, duly emphasised implementation of the SAARC Regional Convention on Suppression of Terrorism and its Additional Protocol, and held it “crucial” for the SAARC countries’ common fight against terrorism. If his speech was not transmitted live, there is no tradition within the SAARC ministerial meetings to be broadcast alive and the crib in the Indian media was not justified. The debate in India on whether it was deliberately ‘blacked out’ should better not have been there at all. The message from the Indian side was loud and clear. India will have a zero tolerance on terrorism and SAARC should do everything possible to stop terror.

Nisar might have brought in the Kashmir issue indirectly but his endorsement of terrorism as fight for freedom was not lost on ministers from other countries, even if he was basically playing to the gallery in his own country. Nawaz also parroted the usual Pakistani line. Could we have expected anything different?

Poor Nawaz is being hounded by the media in Pakistan for allegedly keeping mum on Kashmir issue for about four to five days after Burhan Wani’s killing. There is an oft-chanted slogan in Pakistan television against Nawaz thesedays which was given free run—Modi ka yaar, gaddar, gaddar. He was perhaps compensating for his silence with loaded espousal of the Kashmir cause while addressing the

SAARC ministers. Years of raising the bogey of India as an implacable enemy by the leadership of Pakistan is coming in the way of any idea of reconciliation with India. The narrative has become the consciousness. You cannot expect miracles to happen.

Rather, such exchange of carefully couched barbs between leaders of India and Pakistan is nothing new in SAARC meetings.

Analysts in India should stop taking the visit as a give-away and look at it as a sign of India emerging as a confident power, ready to walk the mile in its commitment to strengthen the process of regional integration under SAARC, as the dominant country in the neighbourhood. If Pakistan resists the idea of multilateral engagement, it will do so at the cost of isolating itself in the regional theatre.

Rather than subjecting such initiatives by the government to exaggerated critical attention, to fill prime-time hours, the media should better focus on myriad issues of social import that deserve greater scrutiny and imaginative intervention.

 

Related Articles

1 Comment

  1. Sidhartha Hazari
    Sidhartha Hazari August 15, 05:41

    Hi Dr Behuria,
    I like the way put the visit of Rajnath Singh to SAARC meeting in a positive prospective. You may say it as a good diplomatic step of Indian govt to move ahead of all the issues both current and old between the two neighboring countries and emerge as a nation with compassion and friendship.
    We are now living in a world of terror and violence which is affecting a lot of nations. So, as a nation like India where it is having tremendous growth in economy and prosperity it is necessary to have good diplomatic relation with neighboring countries. I like the idea of modi govt to send the representative to the meeting.
    Jai Hind.
    Sidhartha hazarcalifornia, us

    Reply to this comment

Write a Comment

Your email address will not be published.
Required fields are marked *

AMARENDRA KHATUA, IFS DG (ICCR & SECRETARY (SPECIAL ASSIGNMENT), MEA speaking on sponsoring of 4 indian authors for Karachi Lite Fest

Diplomacyindia.com Exclusive Video : Egyptian Dancers Performing at SurajKund Mela 2017

Diplomacyindia.com Exclusive Video : Egyptian Artist Performing at SurajKund Mela 2017

Diplomacyindia.com Exclusive Video : Kyrgyz Artist Performing at SurajKund Mela 2017

Diplomacyindia.com Exclusive Video : Kyrgyz Dancers Performing at SurajKund Mela 2017

Diplomacyindia.com Exclusive Video : Kyrgyz Dancers Performing at SurajKund Mela 2017

Exclusive Interview with Prime Minister of Guyana, H.E. Mr. Moses Veerasammy Nagamootoo during his recent visit to India.Highlights of the interview were Indian Cultural Connect, Vibrant Bilateral Ties and Cultural Connect and India’s Economic Prowess.

EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW : Dr. Uttam Sinha, Senior Fellow, IDSA & Expert on Water Diplomacy Speaking on Indus Water Treaty & India’s Diplomatic Options vis-a-vis Pakistan

Glimpses from the Fashion Show organised by the Embassy of Indonesia in New Delhi

Diplomacyindia.com Video : Glimpses from Botswana Independence Day Celebrations organised at the Residence of High Commissioner of Botswana to India. Dancers from Botswana were specially flown to perform.

Diplomacyindia Exclusive Interview : TAIWAN REPRESENTATIVE TO INDIA, H.E. MR. CHUNG KWANG TIEN TAIWAN’S SEEKS MEANINGFUL PARTICIPATION IN ICAO ASSEMBLY

Diplomacyindia Exclusive Video : Glimpses from a Event organised by the Embassy of the Republic of Latvia in India with The Taj Mahal Hotel, New Delhi an exclusive performance by the Riga Saxophone Quartet

Diplomacyindia Exclusive Interview with Vietnam Ambassador to India, H.E. Mr. Ton Sinh Thanh on PM Modi visit to Vietnam in September 2016

Diplomacyindia Exclusve Video : Ambassador of Mexico to India, Ms Melba Pria during the National Anthem of Mexico played at the Reception hosted jointly by Mexico, El Salvador, Costa Rica and Guatemala

Moments from the National Day Reception joined hosted by Mexico, El Salvador, Costa Rica & Guatemala organised in New Delhi, India on 16th September 2016.

Diplomacyindia.com Exclusive Video Interview H.E. Mr. Augusto Montiel, Ambassador of Venezuela to India speaking on preparations, agenda and theme of ongoing 17th Summit of NAM being hosted by Venezuela in Margarita Island.

Diplomacyindia.com Exclusive Interview H.E. Mr. Augusto Montiel, Ambassador of Venezuela to India speaking on preparations, agenda and theme of ongoing 17th Summit of NAM being hosted by Venezuela in Margarita Island Diplomacyindia.com Exclusive Interview with H.E. Mr. Oscar Israel Martinez Cordoves, Cuba Ambassador to India on upcoming NAM Summit in Margarita Island, Venezuela.

Issyk-Kul is an endorheic lake in the northern Tian Shan mountains in eastern Kyrgyzstan. It is the tenth largest lake in the world by volume (though not in surface area), and the second largest saline lake after the Caspian Sea. Issyk-Kul means “warm lake” in the Kyrgyz language; although it is surrounded by snow-capped peaks, it never freezes.

Diplomacyindia.com Exclusive Interview with Ms. Temirbekova Aynura, Kyrgyz Culture, Information & Tourism & Minister at the Press Center, Venue of World Nomad Games 2016

Kok Boru was the highlight of the 2nd edition of World Nomad Games

Diplomacyindia.com Exclusive Interview with Dr. Anirban Ganguly, (@anirbanganguly) Co-Editor of Book, “MODI DOCTRINE” : NEW PARADIGMS IN INDIA’S FOREIGN POLICY & Director, Dr. Syama Prasad Mookerjee Research Foundation Member Policy Research Dept. BJP

Diplomacyindia.com Exclusive Interview with Shri Vijay Chauthaiwale (@vijai63), Co-Editor of Book : “MODI DOCTRINE” , NEW PARADIGMS IN INDIA’S FOREIGN POLICY & Scientist,In-Charge, Foreign Affairs Dept, Bharatiya Janata Party

Diplomacyindia.com Exclusive Interview with Shri Uttam Sinha Co-Editor of Book “MODI DOCTRINE” : NEW PARADIGMS IN INDIA’S FOREIGN POLICY Fellow, Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (IDSA)

Video of Opening Ceremony of World Nomad Games, Issy-kul Kyrgyzstan

Video Message from Shri Prakash Javadekar, MoS (IC) for Forest, Environment & Climate Change on eve of Formal Launch of Website Diplomacyindia.com

Message from Gen. V K Singh, (Retd.) Hon’ble MoS, External Affairs to Diplomacyindia.com

Goodwill Message for Diplomacyindia.com by the Ambassador of Republic of Guinea to India , H.E. Mr. Alexandre Cece Loua

Pictures of Formal Launch of Website Diplomacyindia.com

Goodwill Message from Ambassador of Argentine Republic to India, H.E. Mr. Raúl Ignacio Guastavino

Goodwill Message from Ambassador of Bulgaria to India, H.E. Mr. Petko Doykov on eve of Formal launch of Website Diplomacyindia.com

Goodwill Message from Ambassador of Dominican Republic & Dean of Diplomatic Core in India, H.E. Mr. Frank Hans Dannenberg Castellanos

Goodwill Message from AMBASSADOR OF GUATEMALA TO INDIA, H.E. Mr. Georges de la Roche

Goodwill Message from H.E. MS MELBA PRIA, AMBASSADOR OF MEXICO TO INDIA

Goodwill Message from H.E. Mr. Vladimir Maric, Ambassador of Serbia to India

Goodwill Message from TAIWAN REPRESENTATIVE TO INDIA, H.E. MR. CHUNG KWANG TIEN

Goodwill Message from Ambassador of Turkey to India, H.E. Dr. Burak Akcapar

CALENDAR

February 2017
M T W T F S S
« Jan    
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728  
Facebook Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com